Aerosol Jet Printing of the Active Layer in Polymer Solar Cells, ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces

Product Introduction

Equipment Parameters

I. Core Research Abstract

This work employs ultrasonic aerosol jet printing to fabricate the active layer using two classic organic photovoltaic systems—P3HT:PC₆₀BM and PCBTDPP:PC₇₀BM—and systematically investigates the effects of solvent choice, high-boiling-point additives, and thermal annealing versus solvent vapor annealing on film morphology and device performance.
  1. Solvent Formulation Optimization : Single‑component dichlorobenzene (DCB) readily forms micron‑scale particle protrusions due to rapid solvent evaporation; incorporating a high‑boiling 1,8‑octanedithiol additive can significantly enhance polymer crystallinity without the need for thermal annealing, yielding P3HT‑based devices with a power conversion efficiency of 2.53% and a fill factor as high as 67%.
  2. Revolutionary Conclusions on the Annealing Process : The native thin film of the aerosol has completed molecular self-assembly; high‑temperature thermal annealing induces excessive phase separation in the active layer, leading to performance degradation. Only solvent vapor annealing can effectively optimize the charge‑carrier transport pathways in the PCBTDPP system. After annealing with a DCB/chlorobenzene mixed solvent, small‑area devices achieve an efficiency of 3.92%, while a 1 cm² large‑area module stably delivers 3.14%.
  3. Process Advantage Verification Aerosol printing is maskless, compatible with inks of a wide viscosity range, features an adjustable nozzle–substrate gap, and is resistant to clogging. It enables the continuous, large-area fabrication of uniform polymer active layers, demonstrating the technology’s potential for industrial-scale organic photovoltaics.
Device architecture: ITO/glass substrate | PEDOT:PSS hole-transport layer | Aerosol-printed polymer blend active layer | Ca/Al (P3HT system) / LiF / Al (PCBTDPP system) metal cathode.

II. Complete Operating Principle of Aerosol Jet Printing

This paper employs Ultrasonic atomization aerosol jetting equipment (Optomec M3D-103) , the entire sedimentation process is divided into four major stages:
  • Ultrasonic atomization generates microdroplets.

45W ultrasonic vibration at 30°C generates ultrafine aerosol droplets with a diameter of approximately 15 μm; nitrogen, used as the carrier gas (at 14–20 psi), transports these droplets to the printing nozzle.

  • Sheath gas–airflow focused beam

The nozzle injects coaxial sheath gas at 8–12 psi, forming an annular airflow that encapsulates the aerosol plume and compresses and focuses the microdroplets. Its key advantage is fully addressing the persistent issue of nozzle clogging due to drying in inkjet printing, enabling long‑term continuous operation. The print head can be positioned 3–5 mm from the substrate, making it compatible with curved and uneven surfaces.

  • Base deposition for film formation

The sample stage is maintained at a constant temperature of 40°C, and microdroplets are rapidly impacted onto the substrate to form a liquid film; the film thickness can be precisely controlled by adjusting the ink concentration, the pressure of the carrier/protective gas, the platform’s travel speed, and the number of printing passes.

  • Post-processing molding

The printed thin film can be either used directly or subjected to solvent‑vapor annealing, after which a metal cathode is deposited via vacuum evaporation to complete the device. Unlike spin coating, this process requires no mask throughout; custom CAD‑designed patterns are digitally printed directly.

III. Key Technological Innovations of This Study

Innovation 1: High-performance devices achieved through annealing without thermal treatment, simplifying production-line processes.

Traditional spin-coated organic solar cells require high-temperature annealing at 110–150°C to achieve optimal efficiency; in contrast, during aerosol deposition, the droplets dry slowly, allowing the polymer and fullerene to spontaneously self‑assemble into an ordered structure. The best-performing thin film is fabricated using a DCB ink containing 2 vol% 1,8-octanedithiol. No heat treatment required. This enables an efficiency of 2.53% and an exceptionally high fill factor of 67%, eliminating the need for high-temperature production-line modules, thereby reducing energy consumption and the risk of high-temperature damage to flexible substrates.

Innovation 2: Precise Control of Film Crystallization via High-Boiling-Point Additives

During transport, the single‑component DC solvent evaporates rapidly, causing the solute to aggregate prematurely and form 1‑μm particle protrusions, which significantly increase charge recombination centers. Adding the high‑boiling 1,8‑octanedithiol selectively solvates PC₆₀BM, slowing down the overall solvent evaporation rate; consequently, the characteristic absorption peak at 610 nm in the film is markedly enhanced, demonstrating a substantial increase in the crystallinity of P3HT and a significant reduction in film roughness.

Innovation 3: Mixed Solvents Compatible with the Narrow Bandgap PCBTDPP System

P3HT is compatible with a single solvent plus a high-boiling-point additive, but the narrow-band PCBTDPP polymer exhibits a significant drop in solubility when used with high-boiling-point co‑solvents. To address this, an innovative DCB/chlorobenzene 3:1 mixed solvent was developed, balancing dissolution performance and drying rate while simultaneously enhancing open-circuit voltage and fill factor, thereby providing a dedicated solvent formulation for high‑efficiency organic photovoltaic aerosol printing on narrow bands.

Innovation 4: Solvent annealing–specific optimization for large-area devices

Thermal annealing disrupts the native microphase‑separated structure of the aerosol, but low‑temperature solvent vapor annealing (40°C in a chlorobenzene atmosphere for 1 hour) gently optimizes the charge‑transport pathways in the PCBTDPP system, boosting the short‑circuit current by more than 20% and the fill factor by over 30%. Moreover, a large‑area device with a 1 cm² active area still maintains an efficiency of 3.14%, demonstrating the stability of large‑area printing.

Innovation 5: Wide viscosity compatibility and long-term printing stability

Aerosol ink exhibits a broad viscosity tolerance and is compatible with high-concentration polymer blend slurries; its sheath‑gas encapsulation prevents nozzle clogging, enabling continuous large‑area coating and supporting roll‑to‑roll continuous production lines.

IV. Existing Technical Challenges and the Breakthrough Solutions Proposed in This Paper

    Challenge 1: Single low-boiling-point solvent droplets evaporate rapidly during flight, leaving a thin film riddled with particle defects.

Problem: Solvents with boiling points below 180°C are unsuitable for aerosol‑based processing, and pure DCB–printed films exhibit micron‑scale surface roughness, resulting in a device efficiency of only 1.20%.

✅ Solution: The primary solvent is paired with 1,8-octanedithiol, which has an exceptionally high boiling point of 270°C, to slow down droplet evaporation, prevent premature solute precipitation, and ensure a smooth, particle-free thin film surface.

     Challenge 2: The coffee-ring effect results in excessively thick and non-uniform edge regions of the thin film.

Problem: During the drying of single-component inks, radial flow transports solutes toward the edges, leading to significant variations in film thickness and resulting in performance variability across large-area devices.

✅ Solution: Employ a blended solvent system to modulate the solvent evaporation gradient, suppress internal convection within the droplets, and enhance film uniformity.

     Challenge 3: High-temperature thermal annealing disrupts the native morphology of aerosols.

Issue: Post‑printing high‑temperature annealing induces excessive fullerene aggregation, disrupts phase separation, increases series resistance, and degrades device performance.

✅ Solution: Select post‑processing strategies based on the polymer system: the P3HT system requires no annealing; the PCBTDPP system employs mild solvent‑vapor annealing, with no high‑temperature steps throughout.

    Challenge 4: Poor compatibility between narrow‑band polymers and high‑boiling‑point additives.

Problem: The solubility of PCBTDPP plummets in long-chain, high-boiling-point additives, leading to phase-separation defects in the thin film.

✅ Solution: Abandon high-boiling-point additives and adopt a DCB/chlorobenzene mixed solvent to balance dissolution and drying rates, thereby optimizing both film morphology and light absorption.

    Challenge 5: Printing efficiency drops significantly over large areas.

Problem: The morphology of small-area samples is easy to control, but when the area is scaled up to 1 cm², the leakage current increases and the fill factor decreases.

✅ Solution: Optimize the printing travel speed and employ multi-layer stacking, combined with solvent vapor annealing to reconstruct charge transport pathways, thereby narrowing the efficiency gap between small- and large-scale devices.

V. Future Application Prospects of Aerosol-Printed Organic Photovoltaics

1. Flexible wearable photovoltaic devices

Aerosol‑free, non‑contact printing enables the direct fabrication of ultrathin organic photovoltaics on PET and flexible plastic substrates, making them well suited for smart wristbands, outdoor flexible charging films, and fabric‑integrated solar‑powered textiles—lightweight and free of rigid substrates.

2. Building-integrated curved photovoltaic systems

Traditional coating is limited to flat substrates, whereas the aerosol printing head features an adjustable standoff distance, enabling direct deposition of photovoltaic active layers onto curved curtain walls and irregularly shaped roofs, thus realizing self‑powered components for unconventional architectural forms.

3. Low-cost, large-area roll-to-roll mass production

In contrast to spin-coating, which suffers from extremely low material utilization and inkjet printing, which is prone to nozzle clogging, aerosol-based processes enable continuous belt‑type production, eliminate the need for high‑temperature annealing, streamline the manufacturing line, and significantly reduce large‑scale production costs, making them well suited for megawatt‑scale flexible photovoltaic production lines.

4. Expansion of Layered Organic Photovoltaics

This paper presents two donor‑material systems covering wide- and narrow-bandgap architectures; subsequently, based on these solvents and printing processes, tandem aerosol‑printed solar cells can be developed to further push the upper limit of power conversion efficiency.

5. Specialized Micro-Optoelectronic Devices

Maskless digital printing enables the precise fabrication of micrometer-scale photovoltaic pixels, compatible with miniature sensors and ultra-low-power optically powered IoT chips, thereby realizing miniature self-powered systems.
Image and Text Guide

Figure 1. Schematic diagram of aerosol jet printing, the chemical structures of the materials used in the experiment, and the device architecture. An aerosol generated by ultrasonic treatment of a solution is conveyed from above into the print head under the propulsion of nitrogen (N₂); a sheath gas is introduced laterally into the print head, enveloping the atomized microdroplets to form a fine stream. As numerous microdroplets coalesce, they give rise to a thin liquid film, which subsequently dries on the substrate surface to yield a solid thin film.

Figure 2. Optical microscopy images of thin films fabricated by aerosol jet printing, using: (a) dichlorobenzene; (b) a mixture of dichlorobenzene and 1,8-diiodooctane (at 2 vol %); and (c) a mixture of dichlorobenzene and 1-chlonaphthalene (at 5 vol %). The black dots represent particulate protrusions on the film surface, with dimensions of approximately 1 μm, consistent with the size of microdroplets in the atomizing gas. Scale bar: 10 μm.

Table 1. Summary of device performance for printed thin films prepared using DCB solutions with different additives under simulated solar illumination (AM1.5G, 100 mW/cm²); the device structure is ITO/PEDOT:PSS/P3HT:PC60BM/Ca/Al.

Figure 3. Absorption spectra of P3HT:PC60BM blend films prepared by aerosol jet printing (hollow circles indicate the case with DCB as an additive; solid lines indicate the case with 1,8-octanedithiol added at a volume fraction of 2%).

Figure 4. J–V curves of a P3HT:PC60BM device fabricated by printing from a DCB solution, with 1,8-octanedithiol added at a volume fraction of 2%, under AM1.5G illumination (100 mW/cm²). The inset shows an optical microscopy image of the printed film, with a scale bar of 10 μm.

Figure 5. UV–vis absorption spectra of PCB-TDPP in CB and DCB solutions, as well as in thin films prepared by aerosol jet printing from CB- and DCB-based polymer solutions. The polymer concentration in the solutions is 11 μg/mL.

Figure 6. J–V curves of PCBTDP:PC70BM devices with solvent‑annealed active layers under AM1.5G illumination (100 mW/cm²). The inset shows an optical microscope image of the film, with a scale bar of 10 μm.

Table 2. Summary of Typical Device Characteristics for PCBTDP:PC70BM Devices with Active Layers Printed Using Different Solutions, with or without Solvent Annealing

 



Keywords


Download Materials

Related Products Other Achievements Related Videos

Product Inquiry

Submit Message

*Note: Please ensure that all information provided is accurate and that your contact details are up to date, so we can reach you as soon as possible.