Harbin Institute of Technology, Applied Physics Letters: Voronoi‑based metallic mesh combined with aerosol jet printing enables curved‑surface transparent electromagnetic shielding.

Product Introduction

Equipment Parameters

I. Core Research Summary

This study designs Voronoi‑based metallic mesh topologies with varying degrees of randomness and employs the Optomec aerosol jet printing system to directly write nano‑silver conductive networks onto planar glass and on the curved surface of a 10‑mm‑diameter convex lens. Comprehensive characterization—including optical diffraction, transmittance, and electromagnetic shielding effectiveness in the Ku‑band (12–18 GHz)—was performed. The key findings are as follows:
  • The Voronoi mesh exhibits superior optical performance across the board compared to the conventional random quadrilateral mesh.

Natural, irregular polygonal topology; vertex‑edge counts are randomly distributed; diffraction intensity is discretized and homogenized. At the same transmittance level, the coefficient of variation of diffraction is significantly lower than that of conventional grids, yielding a pronounced stray‑light suppression effect; for 90% of samples with randomization, transmittance can reach 89.88%.

  • Aerosol-based conformal printing of high-precision metallic silver meshes on curved surfaces

On a convex lens with a curvature of 3.7 mm, a uniform silver mesh pattern with an average linewidth of 12.5 μm has been stably fabricated on the curved surface, exhibiting no broken lines or filaments, thereby overcoming the bottleneck of lithography that is limited to planar processing. The planar sample measures 40 × 40 mm, while the curved‑surface lens fully covers the optical effective area.

  • Ku-band stable and efficient electromagnetic shielding performance

12–18 GHz full‑band shielding performance with SE > 23 dB; the silver mesh provides a continuous conductive path that effectively attenuates RF electromagnetic radiation, meeting the shielding requirements of radar systems, vehicle‑mounted electro‑optical equipment, and communication optical windows.

  • Image quality of the curved lens shows no significant degradation.

When a resolution target is imaged through a convex lens covered by a grid, the light intensity distribution is uniform, with no diffraction fringes or ghost images, and the optical imaging accuracy is virtually unaffected by the shielding layer.

  • Digital Rapid Topology Iteration

CAD‑adjustable grid‑based random dithering parameters eliminate the need for photolithographic masks, enabling on‑the‑spot modification of the topology and same‑day printing of both planar and curved samples, thereby significantly shortening the development cycle for optical shielding films.

II. Process Flow and Core Technological Advantages of the Complete Set of Curved-Surface Shielding Meshes for Aerosol Spraying

(1) Complete Preparation Process for Voronoi Metal Shielding Mesh

  • Plasma cleaning of flat glass and convex lens substrates to enhance the adhesion of silver films;
  • NovaCentrix nano-silver ink is atomized by ultrasonic atomization, with an aerosol carrier gas flow rate of 23 sccm and a printing speed of 2 mm/s.
  • A metal grid was directly written using a Voronoi‑based patterning scheme at a 90% randomization level, with a target line width of 10 μm and an average measured line width of 12.5 μm.
  • Cured in a low-temperature oven, the silver layer is dense and resistant to alcohol and water washing.
  • The optical diffraction platform and the vector network analyzer were used to calibrate transmittance and shielding effectiveness, respectively.

(II) Five Core Processes (Photolithography / Evaporation / Screen Printing Compared)

  • Unique advantages of conformal printing on curved surfaces

A 3–5 mm tolerance in spray distance ensures safe operation; convex lenses and arc‑shaped optical components can be directly patterned into continuous conductive silver meshes on curved surfaces, whereas evaporation and photolithography cannot accommodate substrates with complex curvatures.

  • Maskless Digital Topology Rapid Iteration

No custom metal photomasks are required; Voronoi randomness can be adjusted with a single click, and multiple versions of the optical mask can be prototyped in just a few hours, reducing the R&D cycle by 90%.

  • Micron-level fine line formation ensures high light transmittance.

Precisely controls metal wires down to sub‑10‑micron dimensions, with low metal content and high visible‑light transmittance, simultaneously meeting both shielding and imaging requirements.

  • Single-device adaptation plane + multi-curvature optical substrate

A single set of printing parameters is applicable to both soft and hard transparent substrates, such as glass and optical resins, ensuring high versatility across the production line.

  • High consumable utilization, green and low-cost additive manufacturing.

Silver is deposited only in the optical window area, eliminating large‑area coating waste and photolithography etching effluents; for small‑batch samples, the cost is significantly lower than that of vacuum deposition.

III. Five Key Technological Innovations

Innovation 1: Voronoi topology addresses key pain points in the optical diffraction industry.

Unlike conventional quadrilateral fixed grids, its naturally random polygonal structure scatters diffraction spots, significantly reducing stray light and overcoming the longstanding trade-off between shielding and imaging.

Innovation 2: Integrated Manufacturing of Aerosol Curved-Surface Conformal Metal Shielding

A successful attempt has been made to integrate a Voronoi‑based low‑diffraction mesh with aerosol jet printing, enabling the complete fabrication of a continuous conductive silver shielding mesh on convex optical lenses and filling a critical gap in the processing of curved‑surface optoelectronic shielding.

Innovation 3: A System for Quantitative Regulation of Optical Properties via Randomization

A quantitative model relating jitter amplitude to transmittance and diffraction‑induced variation coefficients has been established, enabling precise matching of grid randomization levels to the requirements of optical devices.

Innovative 4 Ku-band broadband curved-surface shielding molding process

A continuous conductive structure based on micron-scale silver mesh eliminates the need for multilayer lamination, achieving a shielding effectiveness of greater than 23 dB in the 12–18 GHz range with a single printed layer.

Innovative 5-Optics – Electromagnetic Dual-Performance Synchronous Verification Platform

Equipped with two standardized test protocols—diffraction imaging and RF shielding—it enables rapid evaluation of the comprehensive performance of curved‑surface shielding films, supporting early‑stage R&D for optoelectronic products.

IV. Current Industry Challenges and Corresponding Solutions for Overcoming Them

Challenge 1: The regular metallic grating produces well-defined diffracted spots, but the resulting image exhibits striped artifacts.

✅ Breaks through Voronoi‑based irregular topology, achieving uniform diffraction energy distribution and significantly suppressing stray‑light interference.

Challenge 2: Lithography and evaporation deposition can only process flat surfaces, making it impossible to deposit shielding grids on curved optical lenses.

✅ Aerosol-based non-contact jet deposition enables direct printing of a complete conductive silver mesh on the curved lens surface.

Challenge 3: In traditional random quadrilateral meshes, transmittance and diffraction‑suppression performance are mutually constrained.

✅ The Voronoi‑structured vertex has no fixed number of edges, and under the same level of light transmission, its diffraction uniformity is significantly improved.

Challenge 4: Vacuum coating equipment is expensive, mask fabrication takes a long time, and redesign costs are high.

✅ Maskless digital direct writing—edit the design and print immediately; sample development can be completed using a desktop aerosol‑based system.

Challenge 5: Curved-surface coating is prone to line breakage and conductive discontinuities, leading to a sharp drop in shielding performance.

✅ Uniform, flexible aerosol deposition ensures consistent silver film thickness across curved surfaces, with no breaks and stable shielding performance.

V. Future Diversified Industrial Application Scenarios

1 In-vehicle AR-HUD / Curved optical shielding for in-vehicle cameras

Integrated high-transmittance EMI shielding for the windshield‑mounted projection lens and the vehicle‑mounted camera’s convex lens, effectively suppressing in‑vehicle RF interference.

2 AR/VR head-mounted optical lenses

Curved Fresnel lens and a low‑diffraction occlusion mesh for the eyepiece, balancing crisp display imaging with electromagnetic isolation for wireless devices.

3 Airborne Electro-Optical Detection Window

Aerospace radar and electro-optical pod curved optical glass, Ku-band electromagnetic shielding, and resistance to electromagnetic clutter from airborne equipment.

4 Infrared temperature measurement, machine vision lenses

Industrial inspection curved‑surface lens, shielding external RF interference to enhance temperature measurement and image‑recognition accuracy.

5. University Optical-Electromagnetic Hybrid Laboratory

Rapid fabrication of various random metal grids, eliminating the need for a vacuum lithography production line and enabling low-cost research and development of optical shielding.
Image and Text Guide

Figure 1. Voronoi diagram and random quadrilateral mesh. (a)–(d): Schematic illustrations of Voronoi diagram generation; (e) and (f): Random quadrilateral meshes with varying degrees of randomness, along with their corresponding Voronoi‑derived mesh structures.

Figure 2. Comparison between a random Voronoi diagram and a random grid. (a) Slope distribution; (b) Diffraction pattern.

Table I. Diffraction Uniformity Analysis of Voronoi Diagrams and Random Quadrilateral Meshes

Figure 3. Fabrication and experimental characterization of Voronoi metallic meshes. (a) Schematic illustration of the AJ printing process. (b) Photograph of a Voronoi metallic mesh. (c) Optical microscopy image of the Voronoi metallic mesh. (d) Schematic diagram of the optical diffraction experiment and the corresponding diffraction pattern. (e) Optical diffraction pattern. (f) and (g) Photographs of the Voronoi metallic mesh positioned in front of an object.

Figure 4. Curved‑surface Voronoi metallic mesh structure. (a) and (b) show schematic diagrams of the Voronoi metallic mesh fabricated on a plano‑convex lens. (c) Optical microscope image of the metallic mesh. (d) Photograph of the sample containing the metallic mesh, captured using the experimental setup. (e) Schematic illustration of the imaging principle for the plano‑convex lens. (f) Photograph of the experimental setup without the metallic mesh. (g) Schematic diagram of the experimental configuration, featuring a plano‑convex lens with a metallic mesh on its curved surface. (h) Normalized light intensity profiles along the marked line in the resolution target images shown in (d) and (f).

Figure 5. Electromagnetic shielding performance of the Voronoi metal mesh. (a) Schematic diagram of the experiment for measuring electromagnetic radiation (SE). (b) Simulated and measured electromagnetic radiation curves.

Download Materials

Related Products Other Achievements Related Videos

Product Inquiry

Submit Message

*Note: Please ensure that all information provided is accurate and that your contact details are up to date, so we can reach you as soon as possible.